Welcome to the Olivia Family Cindy and Maria,
First of all congrats on booking your first Olivia trip, this will be our 5th, but first resort, all others have been Caribbean cruises, this is Ontario after all!!!!!!! lol.... Be prepared to get hooked!!!!!
My wife and I are from Napanee and will likely be flying out of Toronto, although Buffalo is a great, easy airport and is often much cheaper. So far the best I have seen is about $1300 (for both) with one stop. I haven't found a non-stop option, for me would be worth it, (bad ears) but figured I could handle one extra up and down..... I hope.
Look forward to seeing you there, know you will have a blast!!!!!
Cheers Sharon and Lei